ISO/IEC WD 19792 Information technology Security techniques Security evaluation of biometrics

ISO/IEC WD 19792 is a working draft standard that focuses on security evaluation techniques for biometric systems. Biometric systems, which use physiological or behavioral characteristics like fingerprints, facial recognition, or voice patterns for identity verification, play a critical role in various security applications. Ensuring the security and reliability of these systems is essential, and ISO/IEC WD 19792 aims to provide a standardized approach for evaluating their security.

Would you like more detailed information or assistance with a specific aspect of this standard?

What is required ISO/IEC WD 19792 Information technology Security techniques Security evaluation of biometrics

ISO/IEC WD 19792 outlines the requirements and guidelines necessary for the security evaluation of biometric systems. Here’s what is typically required by this standard:

1. Security Evaluation Framework

Establish a comprehensive security evaluation framework tailored specifically for biometric systems. This framework should cover the entire lifecycle of the biometric system, including design, implementation, operation, and maintenance.

2. Threat Modeling

Conduct a thorough threat modeling process to identify potential security threats specific to biometric systems. This includes analyzing the system’s vulnerabilities to various types of attacks, such as spoofing, tampering, or unauthorized access.

3. Security Objectives

Define clear security objectives based on the threat modeling. These objectives should address the protection of biometric data, the integrity of the biometric system, and the prevention of unauthorized access.

4. Evaluation Criteria

Set up detailed evaluation criteria that the biometric system must meet to be considered secure. These criteria should include aspects like data encryption, secure storage, anti-spoofing measures, and robust authentication protocols.

5. Testing and Validation

Implement a rigorous testing and validation process to assess the biometric system’s security against the defined evaluation criteria. This includes both functional and non-functional testing to ensure that the system behaves securely under various conditions.

6. Compliance with Regulations

Ensure that the biometric system complies with relevant legal and regulatory requirements, particularly concerning data protection and privacy. This may involve adherence to laws such as GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation) for systems operating in the European Union.

7. Risk Management

Develop a risk management strategy specific to biometric systems. This strategy should include continuous monitoring for new threats, regular security updates, and a plan for mitigating any identified risks.

8. Documentation

Maintain comprehensive documentation that records the security evaluation process, including threat models, security objectives, testing procedures, and results. This documentation should be accessible for audits and reviews.

9. Audit and Review

Periodically audit and review the biometric system’s security to ensure ongoing compliance with the evaluation criteria and to address any emerging security concerns.

10. Stakeholder Involvement

Engage relevant stakeholders, including developers, users, and regulators, in the security evaluation process to ensure that all security concerns are addressed and that the system meets the needs of its intended environment.

These requirements are designed to ensure that biometric systems are secure, reliable, and capable of protecting sensitive data against a wide range of threats.

Who is required ISO/IEC WD 19792 Information technology Security techniques Security evaluation of biometrics

ISO/IEC WD 19792 is relevant for various stakeholders who play critical roles in the development, implementation, and regulation of biometric systems. These individuals or organizations are required to engage with or comply with this standard:

1. Biometric System Developers and Manufacturers

Software Engineers and Developers: They design and develop biometric algorithms and systems. They need to ensure that their products meet the security requirements specified in the standard.
System Architects: Responsible for the overall design of biometric systems, ensuring that security measures are integrated into the system architecture from the beginning.

2. Security Evaluators and Testers

Security Analysts: Tasked with evaluating the security of biometric systems against the criteria set out in ISO/IEC WD 19792. They identify potential vulnerabilities and assess the effectiveness of security controls.
Penetration Testers and Ethical Hackers: Conduct tests to identify weaknesses in biometric systems and validate the security measures in place.

3. Organizations Implementing Biometric Systems

IT and Security Teams: Organizations that deploy biometric systems must ensure that these systems are secure and comply with the requirements of the standard. This includes banks, government agencies, and companies using biometric authentication.
System Integrators: Professionals responsible for integrating biometric systems into existing IT infrastructures need to ensure that these systems meet the necessary security standards.

4. Compliance and Regulatory Bodies

Regulatory Authorities: Government and industry regulators who oversee the implementation of biometric systems must ensure that these systems adhere to ISO/IEC WD 19792 to protect users and maintain trust.
Internal Compliance Teams: Within organizations, compliance officers and auditors ensure that biometric systems meet internal and external security standards.

5. Consultants and Advisors

Security Consultants: Provide expert advice on implementing and maintaining secure biometric systems in accordance with ISO/IEC WD 19792.
Legal and Compliance Advisors: Ensure that biometric systems comply with legal requirements, such as data protection and privacy laws, which are also addressed by this standard.

6. End-Users and Clients

Organizations Purchasing Biometric Systems: These entities must ensure that the systems they acquire meet the security standards set by ISO/IEC WD 19792 to protect their operations and customer data.

7. Standards Organizations

Standards Development Organizations (SDOs): Entities involved in creating and maintaining international standards must reference ISO/IEC WD 19792 when developing guidelines for biometric security.

Each of these groups has a role in ensuring that biometric systems are secure, reliable, and compliant with ISO/IEC WD 19792, thereby protecting the integrity of biometric data and preventing unauthorized access.

When is required ISO/IEC WD 19792 Information technology Security techniques Security evaluation of biometrics

ISO/IEC WD 19792 is required at various stages in the lifecycle of biometric systems to ensure that these systems are secure and effective. Here’s when this standard is typically required:

1. During System Development

Design Phase: Before the biometric system is fully developed, ISO/IEC WD 19792 should be applied to guide the integration of security features into the system’s design.
Development and Implementation: As the system is being built, developers must follow the standard to ensure that security measures are properly implemented.

2. Before Deployment

Pre-Deployment Testing: Prior to launching the biometric system, comprehensive security evaluations based on ISO/IEC WD 19792 are necessary. This includes testing for vulnerabilities and verifying that the system meets all security requirements.
Compliance Check: Organizations must ensure that the system complies with the standard before it is deployed, particularly in industries with strict regulatory requirements.

3. During Certification and Approval Processes

Regulatory Approval: When seeking certification from regulatory bodies or industry standards organizations, ISO/IEC WD 19792 may be required to demonstrate that the biometric system meets the necessary security standards.
Customer or Client Approval: For systems being delivered to customers, demonstrating compliance with ISO/IEC WD 19792 can be crucial for approval, particularly in sectors like finance, government, or healthcare.

4. Post-Deployment and Maintenance

Ongoing Security Evaluations: After deployment, regular security evaluations are necessary to ensure the biometric system remains secure as new threats emerge. ISO/IEC WD 19792 provides a framework for these ongoing assessments.
System Updates and Modifications: Whenever the system is updated or modified, it should be re-evaluated to ensure continued compliance with the standard.

5. In Response to Security Incidents

Incident Response: If a security breach or vulnerability is discovered in the biometric system, ISO/IEC WD 19792 should be referenced to evaluate the system’s security measures and implement necessary improvements.

6. During Procurement and Contracting

Vendor Selection: Organizations procuring biometric systems may require compliance with ISO/IEC WD 19792 as part of their selection criteria for vendors.
Contractual Obligations: ISO/IEC WD 19792 may be required in contracts to ensure that the delivered biometric system meets specific security standards.

In summary, ISO/IEC WD 19792 is required throughout the entire lifecycle of a biometric system, from initial design and development through to deployment, maintenance, and incident response. Compliance with this standard is essential to ensure the security and integrity of biometric systems at all stages.

Where is required ISO/IEC WD 19792 Information technology Security techniques Security evaluation of biometrics

ISO/IEC WD 19792 is required in various contexts where biometric systems are developed, deployed, or used, ensuring that these systems meet high-security standards. Here’s where this standard is typically required:

1. Industries and Sectors

Financial Services: Banks, payment processors, and other financial institutions use biometric systems for secure customer authentication and fraud prevention. Compliance with ISO/IEC WD 19792 ensures these systems are secure.
Government and Public Sector: Government agencies use biometrics for identity verification in passports, national ID programs, border control, and law enforcement. The standard is essential for maintaining the integrity and security of these systems.
Healthcare: Hospitals and healthcare providers use biometric systems for patient identification and access control to sensitive medical records. Compliance with the standard ensures patient data is protected.
Defense and Military: Defense organizations use biometric systems for secure access control and identity verification. ISO/IEC WD 19792 is required to maintain high-security levels in these sensitive environments.
Technology and Telecommunications: Companies providing IT services, cloud computing, or telecommunications that use biometric systems for authentication and security must comply with the standard to protect user data.

2. Geographical Regions

European Union: In the EU, compliance with ISO/IEC WD 19792 is often necessary due to stringent data protection regulations like the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).
United States: In the U.S., industries subject to federal regulations (such as financial services and healthcare) may require compliance with the standard to meet security and privacy requirements.
Asia and Middle East: Countries in these regions with advanced biometric infrastructure, especially in government services, often require adherence to international security standards like ISO/IEC WD 19792.

3. Regulatory and Compliance Environments

Regulated Industries: In industries such as finance, healthcare, and telecommunications, where regulatory oversight is strict, ISO/IEC WD 19792 is required to ensure that biometric systems comply with industry regulations.
International Standards Compliance: Organizations operating across borders or serving international markets may require ISO/IEC WD 19792 to ensure their biometric systems meet globally recognized security standards.

4. Procurement and Vendor Selection

Public and Private Sector Procurement: When governments or large corporations procure biometric systems, they may require compliance with ISO/IEC WD 19792 as part of the selection criteria to ensure the system’s security and reliability.
Vendor Contracts: Vendors providing biometric solutions may need to demonstrate that their products comply with ISO/IEC WD 19792 to secure contracts with clients, especially those in regulated sectors.

5. Research and Development

R&D Laboratories: Organizations and research institutions developing new biometric technologies may use ISO/IEC WD 19792 to guide the development of secure systems from the early stages of R&D.

6. Certification and Auditing Bodies

Certification Organizations: Bodies that certify biometric systems may require compliance with ISO/IEC WD 19792 as part of their certification process to ensure that systems meet necessary security standards.
Auditing Firms: Auditors evaluating the security of biometric systems may use ISO/IEC WD 19792 as a benchmark for assessing whether systems comply with required security standards.

In summary, ISO/IEC WD 19792 is required wherever biometric systems are used, particularly in industries with high security and regulatory demands, across various geographical regions, and in contexts where international standards compliance is critical.

How is required ISO/IEC WD 19792 Information technology Security techniques Security evaluation of biometrics

ISO/IEC WD 19792 outlines specific requirements and processes to ensure that biometric systems are securely evaluated. The “how” of this standard involves a detailed approach to security evaluation, which includes various methodologies, criteria, and procedures. Here’s how ISO/IEC WD 19792 is typically required:

1. Security Evaluation Criteria

Definition of Security Requirements: Organizations must define security requirements for the biometric system based on its intended use. This involves identifying potential threats, risks, and security objectives.
Assessment Against Threats: The standard requires evaluating the biometric system against a set of known threats, such as spoofing, unauthorized access, and data breaches. This includes testing the system’s resistance to these threats.
Security Controls: Implementing and verifying security controls, such as encryption, access controls, and biometric data protection mechanisms, are essential parts of the evaluation process.

2. Evaluation Methodologies

Penetration Testing: Conducting penetration tests to simulate attacks on the biometric system is required to identify vulnerabilities and assess the system’s resilience.
Performance Testing: Evaluating the system’s performance under various conditions, including stress testing and accuracy assessments, is necessary to ensure that security measures do not compromise functionality.
Conformance Testing: Ensuring that the biometric system conforms to the standard’s specifications through rigorous testing and validation processes is a key requirement.

3. Documentation and Reporting

Comprehensive Documentation: The standard requires detailed documentation of the security evaluation process, including the methods used, results obtained, and any identified vulnerabilities.
Evaluation Reports: Producing formal evaluation reports that summarize the findings of the security assessment, including any recommendations for improvement or mitigation strategies.

4. Certification and Compliance

Certification Process: The standard may be required as part of a formal certification process, where an independent body evaluates the biometric system and certifies its compliance with ISO/IEC WD 19792.
Ongoing Compliance Monitoring: Regular audits and reviews are necessary to ensure that the biometric system continues to meet the security requirements set out in the standard over time.

5. Risk Management and Mitigation

Risk Assessment: Conducting a thorough risk assessment to identify potential security risks associated with the biometric system and evaluating the impact of those risks.
Mitigation Strategies: Developing and implementing strategies to mitigate identified risks, such as updating security protocols, improving system resilience, or enhancing user authentication methods.

6. Stakeholder Involvement

Involvement of Security Experts: Engaging security experts in the evaluation process to ensure that the biometric system is thoroughly assessed from a security perspective.
Collaboration with Developers and Users: Working closely with system developers, integrators, and end-users to ensure that the security evaluation process is comprehensive and addresses all potential vulnerabilities.

7. Legal and Regulatory Compliance

Adherence to Legal Standards: Ensuring that the biometric system complies with relevant legal and regulatory requirements, such as data protection laws, by following the guidelines set out in ISO/IEC WD 19792.
Privacy Considerations: Implementing privacy-preserving techniques and ensuring that the biometric data is handled in accordance with privacy regulations.

8. Post-Evaluation Follow-up

Continuous Monitoring: After the initial evaluation, continuous monitoring of the biometric system is required to detect and respond to new threats or vulnerabilities as they emerge.
System Updates and Re-Evaluation: Whenever the biometric system is updated or modified, it must be re-evaluated to ensure that the changes do not introduce new security risks or compromise existing protections.

In summary, ISO/IEC WD 19792 is required through a systematic approach that includes defining security requirements, conducting rigorous evaluations, documenting findings, and ensuring ongoing compliance. This process involves collaboration among various stakeholders, adherence to legal standards, and continuous monitoring to maintain the security and integrity of biometric systems.

Case Study on ISO/IEC WD 19792 Information technology Security techniques Security evaluation of biometrics

Creating a case study on ISO/IEC WD 19792 involves illustrating how the standard is applied in a real-world scenario to ensure the security of a biometric system. Below is an example case study that highlights the key aspects of implementing and complying with ISO/IEC WD 19792:

Case Study: Securing a National Biometric Identification System

Background

A government agency in Country X decided to implement a national biometric identification system to enhance the security and efficiency of public services. This system would be used for various purposes, including voter registration, social welfare distribution, and border control. Given the sensitive nature of the biometric data involved and the critical role of the system, the agency needed to ensure that the system was secure and compliant with international standards.

Challenge

The main challenge was to evaluate the security of the biometric system comprehensively, ensuring it could resist various threats such as identity theft, unauthorized access, and data breaches. The government required a framework that could guide the security evaluation process and ensure that the system met high-security standards.

Implementation of ISO/IEC WD 19792

Defining Security Requirements
- The first step involved identifying the security requirements for the biometric system. The agency worked with security experts to define potential threats, including spoofing attacks, replay attacks, and unauthorized data access.
- ISO/IEC WD 19792 provided a structured approach to outlining these security requirements, ensuring that all potential risks were considered.
Selecting the Evaluation Methodology
- The agency chose a combination of conformance testing, penetration testing, and performance evaluation as the primary methodologies for assessing the system’s security.
- Using ISO/IEC WD 19792 as a guide, the security team designed tests that would evaluate the system’s resistance to various attacks and its ability to maintain accuracy and reliability under different conditions.
Conducting the Security Evaluation
- Conformance Testing: The system was tested against the specific security requirements outlined in ISO/IEC WD 19792 to ensure it met the standard’s criteria.
- Penetration Testing: Ethical hackers attempted to breach the system using various techniques. The system’s response to these attacks was analyzed to identify vulnerabilities.
- Performance Evaluation: The biometric system was tested under different environmental conditions to assess how well security controls functioned in practice.
Documentation and Reporting
- A comprehensive report was prepared, detailing the security evaluation process, the methodologies used, and the results obtained.
- The report highlighted areas where the system performed well and identified vulnerabilities that needed to be addressed before deployment.
Risk Management and Mitigation
- Based on the evaluation results, the agency identified potential risks, such as vulnerabilities in the data storage and transmission processes.
- Mitigation strategies were developed, including implementing stronger encryption methods, enhancing access controls, and conducting additional training for system administrators.
Certification and Compliance
- The agency sought certification from an independent body to ensure that the system complied with ISO/IEC WD 19792. The certification process involved a thorough review of the evaluation reports and an audit of the system.
- The system successfully obtained certification, demonstrating its compliance with international security standards.
Post-Deployment Monitoring
- After deployment, the system was subject to continuous monitoring to detect and respond to any new threats. The agency used the guidelines from ISO/IEC WD 19792 to conduct regular audits and ensure ongoing compliance.
- The system was also re-evaluated periodically, particularly after any significant updates or modifications, to maintain its security integrity.

Outcome

The implementation of ISO/IEC WD 19792 provided a robust framework for evaluating and securing the national biometric identification system. As a result, the system was able to withstand various security threats and operate reliably across the country. The certification obtained under this standard also increased public trust in the system, ensuring its widespread adoption and success.

The agency’s experience with ISO/IEC WD 19792 demonstrated the importance of a structured approach to security evaluation in safeguarding biometric systems, particularly those used in critical national infrastructure.

This case study illustrates the application of ISO/IEC WD 19792 in a real-world scenario, emphasizing the importance of thorough security evaluation, risk management, and compliance in developing and deploying biometric systems.

White Paper on ISO/IEC WD 19792 Information technology Security techniques Security evaluation of biometrics

Abstract

This white paper provides an overview of ISO/IEC WD 19792, a work-in-progress international standard that outlines security evaluation techniques for biometric systems. The standard aims to establish a consistent and comprehensive framework for assessing the security of biometric technologies, addressing the increasing reliance on biometrics for identity verification and access control. This paper discusses the key elements of the standard, its importance in the current technological landscape, and practical guidance for organizations seeking to implement secure biometric systems.

1. Introduction

Biometric systems, which use physiological or behavioral characteristics for identity verification, have become integral to various sectors, including government, finance, and healthcare. As these systems handle sensitive personal data, ensuring their security is paramount. ISO/IEC WD 19792 addresses this need by providing guidelines for the security evaluation of biometric systems, helping organizations mitigate risks associated with biometric data breaches, spoofing attacks, and other security threats.

2. Scope and Objectives of ISO/IEC WD 19792

ISO/IEC WD 19792 focuses on establishing a security evaluation framework for biometric systems. The primary objectives of the standard include:

Defining Security Requirements: The standard helps organizations identify and document security requirements specific to biometric systems, considering factors such as the intended use, environment, and potential threats.
Evaluation Methodologies: It provides a set of methodologies for assessing the security of biometric systems, including conformance testing, performance testing, and penetration testing.
Risk Management: The standard guides organizations in identifying, assessing, and mitigating risks associated with biometric systems, ensuring that they are robust against various security threats.

3. Key Components of ISO/IEC WD 19792

3.1 Security Evaluation Criteria

The standard outlines specific criteria for evaluating the security of biometric systems. These criteria cover various aspects, including:

Authentication Accuracy: Ensuring that the system accurately distinguishes between genuine users and imposters.
Resistance to Attacks: Assessing the system’s ability to resist attacks such as spoofing, replay attacks, and brute force attempts.
Data Protection: Evaluating the security of biometric data storage, transmission, and processing, with an emphasis on encryption and access control mechanisms.

3.2 Evaluation Methodologies

ISO/IEC WD 19792 provides detailed guidance on the methodologies to be used in security evaluations:

Conformance Testing: Verifying that the biometric system meets the predefined security requirements and specifications.
Penetration Testing: Simulating attacks to identify vulnerabilities in the system’s security architecture.
Performance Testing: Assessing the system’s ability to maintain security and functionality under various operational conditions.

3.3 Risk Management

The standard emphasizes the importance of risk management in the security evaluation process. Key activities include:

Threat Modeling: Identifying potential threats to the biometric system and assessing their impact and likelihood.
Mitigation Strategies: Developing and implementing strategies to address identified risks, such as enhancing encryption protocols or improving user authentication mechanisms.

3.4 Certification and Compliance

ISO/IEC WD 19792 outlines the process for certifying biometric systems, ensuring that they meet the required security standards. This involves:

Third-Party Audits: Engaging independent bodies to evaluate the system’s compliance with the standard.
Ongoing Monitoring: Continuously monitoring the system to ensure it remains secure over time, particularly after updates or modifications.

4. Importance of ISO/IEC WD 19792 in Today’s Technological Landscape

The growing adoption of biometric systems in critical applications has made their security a top priority. ISO/IEC WD 19792 plays a crucial role by providing a structured framework for evaluating the security of these systems, helping organizations protect sensitive biometric data and maintain user trust.

4.1 Mitigating Security Risks

By following the guidelines in ISO/IEC WD 19792, organizations can significantly reduce the risk of security breaches, data theft, and unauthorized access. The standard’s focus on comprehensive risk management and rigorous evaluation methodologies ensures that biometric systems are robust against a wide range of threats.

4.2 Enhancing Regulatory Compliance

As data protection regulations become more stringent, compliance with security standards like ISO/IEC WD 19792 is increasingly important. Adhering to this standard can help organizations meet legal and regulatory requirements, avoiding potential fines and reputational damage.

5. Practical Guidance for Implementing ISO/IEC WD 19792

Organizations looking to implement ISO/IEC WD 19792 can follow these steps:

Identify Security Requirements: Begin by defining the specific security needs of your biometric system, considering factors such as the intended use and the potential risks.
Choose Evaluation Methodologies: Select the appropriate methodologies for your security evaluation, including conformance testing, penetration testing, and performance testing.
Conduct a Thorough Evaluation: Implement the chosen methodologies to assess your biometric system’s security, documenting the process and results.
Address Identified Risks: Develop and implement mitigation strategies to address any vulnerabilities or risks identified during the evaluation.
Seek Certification: Engage an independent body to certify your biometric system’s compliance with ISO/IEC WD 19792, and establish a plan for ongoing monitoring and re-evaluation.

6. Conclusion

ISO/IEC WD 19792 is a vital standard for ensuring the security of biometric systems in today’s increasingly digital world. By providing a comprehensive framework for security evaluation, the standard helps organizations protect sensitive biometric data, mitigate risks, and comply with regulatory requirements. As biometric technologies continue to evolve, adherence to ISO/IEC WD 19792 will be essential for maintaining the trust and security of these systems.

7. References

ISO/IEC WD 19792: “Information technology — Security techniques — Security evaluation of biometrics.”
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 27: “Information security, cybersecurity, and privacy protection.”
Various academic and industry publications on biometric security and risk management.

This white paper provides a comprehensive overview of ISO/IEC WD 19792, discussing its importance, key components, and practical implementation guidance. It serves as a valuable resource for organizations seeking to enhance the security of their biometric systems.